| All-NCOL Football Teams 1922-1944 | * leading NCO scorer | |||
| 1922 picked by Claude M Sharer, Bucyrus Football Coach | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Howard Grindle, Ashland | LE | Clarence Mendenhall, Marion | |
| LT | Paul Unger (c), Bucyrus | LT | Radcliff, Delaware | |
| LG | Paul Wilmore, Mansfield | LG | Harold Knochinsperger, Marion | |
| C | Harold Parcher, Marion | C | Gear, Galion | |
| RG | Garso Warner, Galion | RG | Jesse James, Bucyrus | |
| RT | Don Cooper, Ashland | RT | Ross Gieder, Mansfield | |
| RE | Irvin Brune, Mansfield | RE | Clarence Mackey, Galion | |
| QB | Howard Nussbaum, Bucyrus | QB | George Campbell, Ashland | |
| LH | * Harold Smith, Bucyrus | LH | Herb Ganyard, Ashland | |
| RH | Charles Newsome, Ashland | RH | Veto Pesano, Mansfield | |
| FB | Henry Isaly, Mansfield | FB | George Harris, Bucyrus | |
| 1923 picked by Ashland Times-Gazette | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | George Percy, Mansfield | LE | Kenneth Ness, Galion | |
| LT | Ted Brownlee, Harding | LT | Evans, Galion | |
| LG | Paul Wilmore, Mansfield | LG | Meritt Cobb, Marion Harding | |
| C | Harold Parcher, Marion | C | Charles "Kid" Ghist, Bucyrus | |
| RG | Clarence Mackey, Galion | RG | Maurice Johnson, Ashland | |
| RT | Harold Smith, Bucyrus | RT | Harold Eller, Mansfield | |
| RE | Fred Ferguson, Mansfield | RE | Eddie Norton, Bucyrus | |
| QB | Gail Doan, Harding (c) | QB | Mark McElroy, Mansfield | |
| LH | Paul Todhunter, Galion | LH | George Harris, Bucyrus (c) | |
| RH | Charles Newsome, Ashland | RH | George Doran, Galion | |
| FB | * Clarence Mendenhall,Marion | FB | Steve Newhouse, Galion | |
| 1924 picked by Mansfield News | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | George Percy, Mansfield | LE | Alex Kish, Bucyrus | |
| LT | Meritt Cobb, Marion | LT | Shuster, Delaware | |
| LG | Bob Schuler, Mansfield | LG | Ivan Cass, Galion | |
| C | Ken Nunguesser, Galion | C | Delbert Caton, Ashland | |
| RG | Main, Delaware | RG | Wilfred Bennett, Bucyrus | |
| RT | George Riggle, Ashland | RT | Ken Bolesky, Mansfield | |
| RE | Stan Kruger, Galion | RE | Frank Richards, Mansfield | |
| QB | Howard Nussbaum, Bucyrus | QB | Ziegler, Delaware | |
| LH | * Arnold Meeker, Galion | LH | Wayne Schreck, Galion | |
| RH | Stuart, Delaware | RH | Philip Plemesich, Mansfield | |
| FB | Ken Ness, Galion | FB | Coackley, Delaware | |
| 1925 picked by the Ashland Times-Gazette - Sports Editor - Bozo | ||||
| LE | Orman Peck, Delaware | LE | Bill Smith, Ashland | |
| LT | Don McEntire, Ashland | LT | Frederick Crall, Bucyrus | |
| LG | Parker Benedict, Mansfield | LG | William Schorr, Marion | |
| C | Delbert Caton, Ashland | C | Ken Nunguesser, Galion (c) | |
| RG | Jack Doubly, Marion | RG | Charles Sharrock, Bucyrus | |
| RT | Walter Elliott, Shelby (c) | RT | Marshall McCuen, Ashland | |
| RE | Alex Kish, Bucyrus | RE | Frank Richards, Mansfield | |
| QB | Maurice Johnson, Ashland | QB | Fred Green, Shelby | |
| LH | * Elson Norris, Bucyrus | LH | George Jonsson, Marion | |
| RH | William Query, Ashland | RH | Carrol Born, Marion | |
| FB | James McWhorton, Marion | FB | Harold "Doc" Seaton, Shelby | |
| 1926 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland Times Gazette | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Silas Robinson, Mansfield | LE | Robert Martin, Mansfield | |
| LT | Earl "Red" Evans, Delaware | LT | Charles McElroy, Marion | |
| LG | Philip Malo, Marion | LG | Ralph Everly, Galion | |
| C | Bob Stock, Shelby | C | Fred Larue, Ashland | |
| RG | Tony DiGiacomo, Mansfield | RG | Charles Sharrock, Bucyrus | |
| RT | Ray Miller, Ashland | RT | John Angle, Mansfield | |
| RE | Walter Bricker, Shelby | RE | Lewin Vermillion, Ashland | |
| QB | Walter Merchant, Marion | QB | Clarence Yetzer, Shelby | |
| LH | Paul Johnson, Ashland | LH | Forrest Campbell, Delaware | |
| RH | * Frank McMullen, Mansfield | RH | Robert Monnett, Bucyrus | |
| FB | Alex Kish, Bucyrus | FB | Dewitt Kersh, Galion | |
| 1927 picked by Sports Ed. of the Four NCO Papers | ||||
| Bill McKee- Ashland T-G, Steve Stahl- Mans. News, Tom Buchanan-Marion Star, Bucyrus | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Silas Robinson, Mansfield | LE | Edward Houghton, Marion | |
| LT | Paul Guerin, Shelby | LT | Russell Herschler, Bucyrus | |
| LG | Richard Gongwer, Ashland | LG | Earl McMullen, Mansfield | |
| C | Bob Stock, Shelby | C | Fred Larue, Ashland | |
| RG | Charles Kramer, Marion | RG | Dick O'Brien, Bucyrus | |
| RT | Davis, Mansfield | RT | Dave Kiefer, Ashland | |
| RE | Lewis, Shelby | RE | Bill Shaw, Shelby | |
| QB | Paul Johnson, Ashland | QB | * Frank McMullen, Mansfield | |
| LH | Dick McAninch, Marion | LH | George Stafford, Marion | |
| RH | Robert Monnett, Bucyrus | RH | Floyd Davis, Shelby | |
| FB | Kermit Perkins, Mansfield | FB | Dewitt Kersh, Galion | |
| 1928 picked by fans in the Ashland Times-Gazette | Mansfield News | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | Phil Premisich, Editor | ||
| LE | Charles Deardorf, Shelby | LE | Hal Culbertson, Shelby | Silas Robinson, Mansfield |
| LT | Dave Kiefer, Ashland | LT | William Woessner, Marion | Ansley, Marion |
| LG | Earl McMullen, Mansfield | LG | McClure, Marion | Earl McMullen, Mansfield |
| C | Edward Heimquist, Mansfield | C | Fred Haberman, Marion | Edward Heimquist, Mansfield |
| RG | Jack Skiles, Shelby | RG | Dick Bear, Ashland | Herman Oxman, Shelby |
| RT | Paul Mackey, Galion | RT | Kyle, Mansfield | Paul Mackey, Galion |
| RE | Claude Perry, Marion | RE | Ford, Mansfield | Art Shreffler, Shelby |
| QB | Dick McAninch, Marion | QB | Bride, Mansfield | Dick McAninch, Marion |
| LH | * Silas Robinson, Mansfield | LH | Dick Riedel, Shelby | Robert Monnett, Bucyrus |
| RH | Robert Monnett, Bucyrus | RH | Art LaBarge, Shelby | Dick Riedel, Shelby |
| FB | Robert Zinn, Galion | FB | Dick Paxton, Ashland | Robert Zinn, Galion |
| 1929 picked by Consensus 4 NCO papers: | ||||
| Mansfield News, Bucyrus Telegraph-Forum, Shelby Globe, Ashland T-G | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Jim Baker, Bucyrus | LE | George Hummel, Mansfield | |
| LT | Paul Mackey, Galion | LT | Robert Angle, Mansfield | |
| LG | Dick Bear, Ashland | LG | Ned Brooks, Mansfield | |
| C | Edward Heimquist, Mansfield | C | Roger Roberts, Ashland | |
| RG | Jack Skiles, Shelby | RG | Dick Isaly, Marion | |
| RT | Charles Huber, Shelby | RT | Melville Sperry, Galion | |
| RE | Harold Bensinger, Ashland | RE | Ed Hockstra, Galion | |
| QB | * Eugene Earick, Mansfield | B | John Castner, Marion | |
| LH | Willard Talbott, Bucyrus | B | Charles McKinney, Mansfield | |
| RH | George Fetter, Mansfield | B | Emmett Lerch, Bucyrus | |
| FB | Art Shreffler, Shelby | B | George Fridrichs, Galion | |
| 1930 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland Times-Gazette | Marion Star's picks | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | 1st Team | ||
| LE | Ed Hoekstra, Galion | LE | Rowley LaPointe, Bucyrus | Ed Hoekstra, Galion |
| LT | Harry Smith, Ashland | LT | Elmer Shaffer, Bucyrus | Vern Heiser, Mansfield |
| LG | Holden Miller, Bucyrus | LG | Dean Morgan, Ashland | Ned Brooks, Mansfield |
| C | Garth Oberlander, Bucyrus | C | Charles Yuncker, Galion | Bob Fichter, Mansfield |
| RG | Ned Brooks, Mansfield | RG | Bill Jevas, Marion | Holden Miller, Bucyrus |
| RT | Junior Clay, Marion | RT | Herb Smith, Ashland | Harry Smith, Ashland |
| RE | Lawrence McMillen, Ashland | RE | Doyle DeWalt, Galion | Lawrence McMillen, Ashland |
| QB | Willard Talbott, Bucyrus | QB | Frank Fisch, Mansfield | Willard Talbott, Bucyrus |
| LH | Cy McKinney, Mansfield | LH | Don Burnison,Galion | John Matthews, Ashland |
| RH | John Matthews, Ashland | RH | * Bob Rybolt, Ashland | Cy McKinney, Mansfield |
| FB | Harvey Smith, Galion | FB | George Swanger, Shelby | Harvey Smith, Galion |
| 1931 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland Times-Gazette | Marion Star's picks | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | 1st Team | ||
| LE | Chuck Campbell, Ashland | LE | Chuck McMullen, Mansfield | Earl Thomas, Ashland |
| LT | Harry Smith, Ashland | LT | Inwood Smith, Mansfield | Foltz, Marion |
| LG | Cilff Ohle, Mansfield | LG | Bill Jevas, Marion | Roger Senseman, Ashland |
| C | John Depler, Ashland | C | Bob Fichter, Mansfield | Bob Fichter, Mansfield |
| RG | LeRoy Fredericks, Mansfield | RG | Holden Miller, Bucyrus | Williams, Marion |
| RT | Ray Simmons, Mansfield | RT | Everett Hesson, Ashland | Harry Smith, Ashland |
| RE | Clayton Luckie, Mansfield | RE | Rowley LaPointe, Bucyrus | Clayton Luckie, Mansfield |
| QB | * Frank Fisch, Mansfield | QB | Dick Morgan, Marion | Willard Talbott, Bucyrus |
| LH | Willard Talbott, Bucyrus | LH | Charles Grubaugh, Mansfield | Gene Brandon, Mansfield |
| RH | Nick Dolby, Ashland | RH | Gene Brandon, Mansfield | Jim Miller, Shelby |
| FB | Jim Miller, Shelby | FB | Bob Selby, Mansfield | Sweeterman, Mansfield |
| 1932 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland T-G | All-Writer's NCO 11 | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Earl Thomas, Ashland | LE | Becker Jenkins, Mansfield | Charles Sharkey, Shelby |
| LT | Inwood Smith, Mansfield | LT | Don Heter, Ashland | Inwood Smith, Mansfield |
| LG | Roger Wicks, Ashland | LG | Ray Simmons, Mansfield | Ray Simmons, Mansfield |
| C | John Depler, Ashland | C | William Mautz, Marion | John Depler, Ashland |
| RG | Cliff Ohle, Mansfield | RG | Roger Senseman, Ashland | Cliff Ohle, Mansfield |
| RT | Everett Hesson, Ashland | RT | Glen Loveland, Shelby | Don Heter, Ashland |
| RE | Charles Sharkey, Shelby | RE | Carl Gerlach, Ashland | Becker Jenkins, Mansfield |
| QB | Nick Dolby, Ashland | QB | Charles Grubaugh, Galion | Nick Dolby, Ashland |
| LH | * Gene Brandon, Mansfield | LH | Orville LaBarge, Shelby | Gene Brandon, Mansfield |
| RH | Bob Selby, Mansfield | RH | Lawrence Fry, Shelby | Charles Grubaugh, Galion |
| FB | Jim Southard, Shelby | FB | Murray Whitcum, Marion | Jim Southard, Shelby |
| Bob Selby, Mansfield | ||||
| 1933 picked by the Shelby Globe | Galion Inquirer's Picks | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | 1st Team | ||
| LE | Paul Wilcox, Shelby | LE | Howard Poole, Mansfield | Frank Zercher, Ashland |
| LT | Andy Douds, Shelby | LT | Glen Hockenshilt, Shelby | Don Heter, Ashland |
| LG | Bud Weber, Shelby | LG | Thomas Zuck, Marion | Bud Weber, Shelby |
| C | John Depler, Ashland | C | Daryl Cobb, Shelby | John Depler, Ashland |
| RG | Andy Horvath, Mansfield | RG | Dick Miller, Mansfield | Andy Douds, Shelby |
| RT | Jack Lacey, Ashland | RT | Don Heter, Ashland | Glen Hockenshilt, Shelby |
| RE | Frank Zercher, Ashland | RE | Grant Clark, Ashland | Schuster, Mansfield |
| QB | Orville LaBarge, Shelby | QB | Ed Zediker, Mansfield | Orville LaBarge, Shelby |
| LH | * Becker Jenkins, Mansfield | LH | Bob Fisher, Shelby | Becker Jenkins, Mansfield |
| RH | Murray Whitcum, Marion | RH | Ken Grubaugh, Mansfield | Ken Gurbaugh, Mansfield |
| FB | Lawrence Fry, Shelby | FB | Dick Olin, Mansfield | Dick Olin, Mansfield |
| Mansfield | ||||
| 1934 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland Times-Gazette | News-Journal | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | Oscar Ruhl, Editor | ||
| LE | Gib Clark Ashland | LE | Frederick, Galion | Gib Clark Ashland |
| LT | Clarence Risser, Ashland | LT | Don Heter, Ashland | Don Heter, Ashland |
| LG | Quinton Walker, Marion | LG | Andy Horvath, Mansfield | Andy Horvath, Mansfield |
| C | Jack Lacey, Ashland | C | Tom Dehart, Mansfield | Jack Lacey, Ashland |
| RG | Dick Miller, Mansfield | RG | Junior Gates, Shelby | Quinton Walker, Marion |
| RT | Harold Strine, Ashland | RT | Charles Prim, Galion | Dick Miller, Mansfield |
| RE | Howard Poole, Mansfield | RE | Paul Parker, Ashland | Howard Poole, Mansfield |
| QB | Bus Hockensmith, Ashland | QB | Rex Frazier, Marion | Bus Hockensmith, Ashland |
| LH | Paul Wilcox, Shelby | LH | Chuck Morrison, Ashland | Paul Wilcox, Shelby |
| RH | Pete Hathaway, Ashland | RH | * Bart Clement, Mansfield | Bart Clement, Mansfield |
| FB | Dick Olin, Mansfield | FB | Nick Weber, Mansfield | Pete Hathaway, Ashland |
| Mansfield | ||||
| 1935 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland Times-Gazette | News-Journal | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | Oscar Ruhl, Editor | ||
| LE | Bud Plank, Ashland | LE | Dwight Ruby, Marion | Bud Plank, Ashland |
| LT | Dwight Carhart, Marion | LT | Wayne Taylor, Mansfield | Roger Ernsberger, Shelby |
| LG | Clarence Risser, Ashland | LG | Harry Myers, Galion | Gaylord Bucher, Mansfield |
| C | Joseph Lacey, Ashland | C | Bill Locke, Mansfield | Bill Locke, Mansfield |
| RG | George Noland, Shelby | RG | Eugene Puglisi, Ashland | Harry Myers, Galion |
| RT | Roger Ernsberger, Shelby | RT | Robert Aungst, Mansfield | Robert Aungst, Mansfield |
| RE | Bill Bollantz, Mansfield | RE | Rine, Mt. Vernon | Bill Bollantz, Mansfield |
| B | Nick Weber, Mansfield | B | Rex Frazier, Marion | Nick Weber, Mansfield |
| B | Bus Hockensmith, Ashland | B | Bill Distl, Mansfield | Bus Hockensmith, Ashland |
| B | Charley Clabaugh, Galion | B | Joe Harvath, Ashland | Rex Frazier, Marion |
| B | * Charles Hart, Shelby | B | Ray Fridrichs, Galion | Charles Hart, Shelby |
| Mt Vernon | ||||
| 1936 picked by Bill McKee, Ashland Times-Gazette | Rep-Banner | |||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | R.V. Hess, Sports Editor | ||
| LE | Virg Scobey, Ashland | LE | Harold Luckie, Mansfield | Virg Scobey, Ashland |
| LT | Willie Glasener, Ashland | LT | Myers, Mt. Vernon | Frank Bordonaro, Ashland |
| LG | Clarence Risser, Ashland | LG | Joe Miller, Shelby | Gaylord Bucher, Mansfield |
| C | Steve Olin, Mansfield | C | Bill Locke, Mansfield | Steve Olin, Mansfield |
| RG | Gaylord Bucher, Mansfield | RG | Thomas, Mt. Vernon | Thomas, Mt. Vernon |
| RT | Daryl Heiser, Mansfield | RT | Frank Bordonaro, Ashland | Daryl Heiser, Mansfield |
| RE | Ray Hudson, Marion | RE | Ed Chatlain, Mansfield | Harold Luckie, Mansfield |
| QB | * Johnny Hallabrin, Mansfield | QB | Bus Hockensmith, Ashland | Johnny Hallabrin, Mansfield |
| LH | Bill Distl, Mansfield | LH | Joe Caprino, Marion | Payne, Mt. Vernon |
| RH | Dwight Bumpus, Mt. Vernon | RH | Payne, Mt. Vernon | Dwight Bumpus, Mt. Vernon |
| FB | Pudge Clark, Ashland | FB | Al Banks, Mansfield | Wayne Newell, Ashland |
| 1937 picked by Galion Inquirer's Writers & Advisors | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Bill Yosick, Shelby | LE | Thompson, Mt. Vernon | |
| LT | Bob Hocker, Galion | LT | Yoakum, Mt. Vernon | |
| LG | Workman, Mt. Vernon | LG | Al Hocker, Galion | |
| C | Larry Maidens, Galion | C | Paul Fick, Marion | |
| RG | Merle Kleinnecht, Galion | RG | Harold LaRue, Bucyrus | |
| RT | Jack Stephenson, Marion | RT | John Patterson, Galion | |
| RE | Dick Kump, Galion | RE | Howard Diehl, Marion | |
| QB | Robert Castner, Marion | QB | Casto Ramsey, Galion | |
| LH | * Dwight Bumpus, Mt Vernon | LH | Harold Bliss, Shelby | |
| RH | Williams, Marion | RH | Bill Durtschi, Galion | |
| FB | Fred Staub, Galion | FB | Dick Shackelford, Bucyrus | |
| 1938 picked by the Sport Writers of the Six Teams | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team: | |||
| LE | Bill Yosick, Shelby | LE | Dick Secrest, Galion | |
| LT | Bob Payne, Shelby | LT | Forrest Gary, Bucyrus | |
| LG | George George, Shelby | LG | Allen Hocker, Galion | |
| C | Larry Maidens, Galion | C | Bob Stevens, Shelby | |
| RG | Merl Kleinknecht, Galion | RG | Walter Ackerman, Mt. Vernon | |
| RT | Paul Chorpening, Ashland | RT | Charles Baker, Marion | |
| RE | Dick Kump, Galion | RE | Cecil Souders, Bucyrus | |
| QB | Casto Ramsey, Galion | QB | Joe Miller, Shelby | |
| LH | * Bob Baker, Shelby | LH | Mervin Nugent, Mt. Vernon | |
| RH | Bill Durtschi, Galion | RH | Carlos Frazier, Marion | |
| FB | Harold Bliss, Shelby | FB | Eugene Jacks, Galion | |
| 1939 picked by the Sport Writers of the Six Teams | ||||
| 1st Team: | 2nd Team: | |||
| LE | Ernie Thompson, Mt. Vernon | LE | Jack Lewis, Marion | |
| LT | Pete Bascos, Marion | LT | Bob Shupp, Galion | |
| LG | Warren McGinnis, Mansfield | LG | Wayne Short, Marion | |
| C | King Keller, Marion | C | Howard McNabb, Ashland | |
| RG | Bill Berry, Ashland | RG | Don Haverfield, Shelby | |
| RT | Cliff Cothren, Ashland | RT | Bob Ziesler, Marion | |
| RE | Bob Lehman, Shelby | RE | Owen Cressap, Marion | |
| B | Bill Yosick, Shelby | B | Morgan Shaw, Marion | |
| B | John Roberts, Marion | B | Bill Walters, Marion | |
| B | Dwight Harris, Mt Vernon | B | Bill Durtschi, Galion | |
| B | * Russell Reichart, Marion | B | Phil Falter, Mt Vernon | |
| 1940 picked by the NCO Sports Writers | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| LE | Richard Whitney, Shelby | LE | Shirley "Pete" Risser, Ashland | |
| LT | William Braden, Mt. Vernon | LT | Pete Bascos, Marion | |
| LG | Wayne Short, Marion | LG | Dean Hunter, Shelby | |
| C | King Keller, Marion | C | Carroll Spurlock, Bucyrus | |
| RG | Robert Bonin, Bucyrus | RG | Ralph Hurst, Ashland | |
| RT | John Hazelwood, Shelby | RT | Ted Heckler, Bucyrus | |
| RE | Owen Creasap, Marion | B | Howard Richardson, Marion | |
| B | * James Leuthold, Bucyrus | B | Junior Bonecutter, Shelby | |
| B | Robert Laubie, Shelby | B | James Shull, Ashland | |
| B | Wayne Ferguson, Marion | B | Carson Kanode, Bucyrus | |
| B | James Gilson, Galion | B | Phillip Falter, Mt. Vernon | |
| 1941 picked by the NCO Sports Writers | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| E | Pete Ransom, Mt. Vernon | E | Dean Cooperrider, Bucyrus | |
| T | Lowell Gottfried, Galion | T | Bill Fate, Marion | |
| G | Martin Lewis, Marion | G | Don Ryland, Shelby | |
| C | Glenn Martin, Ashland | C | Tom Hurst, Marion | |
| G | George Culbertson, Mt. Vern | G | Jim Turner, Marion | |
| T | Ralph Hurst, Ashland | T | Paul Grimes, Ashland | |
| E | Bob Kemmerly, Marion | E | Charles Bowers, Marion | |
| B | * Bob Laubie, Shelby | B | Bob Dove, Ashland | |
| B | Jim Shull, Ashland | B | Bob Puglisi, Ashland | |
| B | Day Hurst, Marion | B | Ed Wright, Mt.Vernon | |
| B | Leo Strang, Ashland | B | George York, Shelby | |
| B | Charles Roberts, Marion | B | Leroy Harvey, Marion | |
| 1942 picked by Six NCO Sports Writers | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| E | Robert Picking, Ashland | E | Kenneth Deisch, Galion | |
| T | Glenn Martin, Ashland | T | Val Ramsey, Galion | |
| G | Thomas Boyd, Marion | G | Burdette Finley, Ashland | |
| C | William Lybargor, Mt Vernon | C | Arthur Teynor, Bucyrus | |
| G | Bernard Ernst, Galion | G | Herman Rittenour, Bucyrus | |
| T | Don Kay, Marion | T | Harry Crawford, Shelby | |
| E | Keith Williams, Marion | E | Donald Benedict, Marion | |
| B | Leo Strang, Ashland | B | William Stoner, Galion | |
| B | * Harold Jenkins, Marion | B | John Landis, Bucyrus | |
| B | William Wright, Mt. Vernon | B | Don Broderick, Shelby | |
| B | Robert Puglisi, Ashland | B | Emory Shaffer, Galion | |
| B | Robert Dove, Ashland | |||
| B | Leroy Harvey, Marion | |||
| 1943 picked by NCO Sports Writers | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| E | Harley Jones, Shelby | E | Salvadore Medrano, Galion | |
| T | Charles Fazio, Marion | T | James Gatchell, Bucyrus | |
| G | Richard Patterson, Ashland | G | James Tharp, Ashland | |
| C | Elvin Beach, Marion | C | Thomas Hoffman, Ashland | |
| G | Herbert Durtschi, Galion | G | Herman Rittenhour, Bucyrus | |
| T | Western Wiles, Ashland | T | Joseph Garns, Shelby | |
| E | Jack Schuck, Bucyrus | E | Jack Beam, Marion | |
| B | * Robert Dove, Ashland | B | Jack Koeppen, Marion | |
| B | Stewart Young, Marion | B | John Landis, Bucyrus | |
| B | Salvator DeVito, Shelby | B | Bernard Lanning, Mt. Vernon | |
| B | Emery Shaffer, Galion | B | Bob Roberts, Shelby | |
| 1944 picked by NCO Sports Writers | ||||
| 1st Team | 2nd Team | |||
| E | Norman Dillinger, Marion | E | Robert Carpenter, Shelby | |
| T | Western Wiles, Ashland | T | Richard Durtschi, Galion | |
| G | Merle McKinley, Ashland | G | David Lee, Marion | |
| C | John White Shelby | C | Richard Stauffer, Ashland | |
| G | Arthur Thoman, Galion | G | Donald Wolfelt, Galion | |
| T | Robert Strobel, Marion | T | Robert Miller, Shelby | |
| E | Joseph McGuire, Galion | E | Eugene Plummer, Galion | |
| B | * Bernard Lanning, Mt. Vernon | B | James Zimmerman, Ashland | |
| B | Jack Robb, Shelby | B | Ralph Ramsey, Galion | |
| B | Elvin Beach, Marion | B | Archie Steele, Shelby | |
| B | Charles Griebling, Galion | B | Robert Patterson, Ashland | |